Low-Income Students

Learning to Listen. Listening to Learn.

Children singing

I was poking around an old collection of NPR Ed Blogs that I found interesting and came across this article on Language cognition. To read the full reporting click here.

In the report, Cory Turner explores the work of the Harmony Project, an organization that works with low-income schools in the Los Angeles area to provide music education to the community’s children.

Very few people would deny the value of adding music instruction to a person’s day. For years, people have linked music instruction to all sorts of brain goodies: math skills, test scores, attendance rates, you name it. This one struck me as particularly important, though. Nina Kraus at Northwestern University studied participants in the Harmony Project to analyze their brain activity. In the study, she identifies that students from low-income communities often hear fewer words by the age of 5 than their wealthier peers. As a result, some kids enter into school unable to differentiate between language and other noise as clearly as their classmates, making it more difficult to understand instruction and communicate.

Kraus found that students in music classes provided by the Harmony Project were closing this gap. Kids who make music develop the ability to categorize pitch, timbre, and timing. While these skills are important to good music performance, they are crucial to understanding speech sounds as well. Kraus found that, as students developed musically, they also learned to block out “neural noise” that hindered their ability to learn and communicate.

Credit: LA Johnson and Alyson Hurt/NPR

Credit: LA Johnson and Alyson Hurt/NPR

This neural noise is the equivalent of hearing static or white noise…all the time. This has to be incredibly distracting and would certainly explain why some kids are harder to reach. Kids with active parents hear and participate in speech sounds, singing sounds, and experimenting with their voices, which leads to an acute ability to identify and block out neural noise in early childhood. To ensure that all students develop this skill, every kid needs the benefit of this seemingly “silly” playtime. Where better to do that than in a music class?

The more I read about kids who are “behavior problems,” the more I believe they need access to joy and beauty far more than they need rules and structure (although the latter are important too). I’m glad to see that this belief is supported by real brain science that proves it will help them develop cognitively as well as personally. Let’s spend less time trying to subjugate kids into quiet compliance, and more time encouraging them to make a joyful noise!

Public Education’s Poor Majority

A recent study by the Southern Education Foundation  suggests a hard reality for American public schools. According to a U.S. Department of Education survey of Free And Reduced lunch statistics, more than half of American public school students now live below the poverty line. This troubling reality is more significant in Texas, who ranks 6th in the nation in student poverty, with 60% of Texas kids coming from impoverished households.

Percentage of Low Income Students by state 2013

The study also suggests that American’s must reconsider previously held beliefs about the geographic reality of poverty. No longer can suburban school districts pretend to ignore this issue. The misconception that poor students are solely the responsibility of rural and inner-city schools is simply not true. According to Steve Suitts, the Foundation’s Vice president, “Even in the suburbs, low-income students are now 40% of the student population in the public schools…It’s everyone’s problem.”

Without improving the educational support that the nation provides its low income students – students with the largest needs and usually with the least support — the trends of the last decade will be prologue for a nation not at risk, but a nation in decline

“A New Majority: Low Income Students in the South and Nation. The Southern Education Foundation (2013)

This is an important statistic for educators to consider, as low-income students often require a more expensive education than their wealthier peers. Schools who service impoverished learners must account for the obvious gaps in resources. However, we must also consider the needs of kids who will not benefit of after school enrichment, summer camps, and families with the time and resources to help students grow at home. Most families want for their kids to learn and grow, but many do not have the time or money to give that desire a backbone. This is where schools have to pick up the baton.

As the Texas Legislature considers important school funding bills for the next biennium, it is imperative that they take into account the needs our State’s kids. Educators will need greater resources to provide for the new majority in Texas public schools. “Doing more with less” is simply not an option. The “more” these kids need is far too great to ignore and de-fund. If Texas lawmakers believe that our children are, in fact, an important resource for our State’s future, they simply must put their money where their mouth is.

Additionally, schools need flexibility with this funding to provide kids with services that might not have traditionally been within the scope of public education. Innovate teachers across the state will take the initiative to give all Texas kids what they need, but they need the time and money to make it happen. They also need the flexibility to do what’s best for their students and their community. School funding structures need to allow for this flexibility so campuses can make the important decisions they need to create school days that best serve the growing population of learner/breadwinners that go to school and support their families.

This issue is not just a political issue, it is a central economic reality for our State and our Nation. The strength of our National economy is dependent on the next generation of learners. The Foundation’s report says it best. “No longer can we consider the problems and needs of low income students simply a matter of fairness…Their success or failure in the public schools will determine the entire body of human capital and educational potential that the nation will possess in the future. Without improving the educational support that the nation provides its low income students – students with the largest needs and usually with the least support — the trends of the last decade will be prologue for a nation not at risk, but a
nation in decline”

No longer can we consider the problems and needs of low income students simply a matter of fairness…Their success or failure in the public schools will determine the entire body of human capital and educational potential that the nation will possess in the future.

“A New Majority: Low Income Students in the South and Nation. The Southern Education Foundation (2013)